
Windsor Hills vs Windsor Island: Design Compared
Windsor Hills and Windsor Island share a name and not much else. One is an established gated resort in Kissimmee with a mix of condos, townhomes and houses. The other is a newer Davenport community built around larger homes with private pools. Owners comparing them often ask which is a better place to buy. This guide leaves price, fees and distance to your agent and the HOA. We look at one thing: how the inside of the house should be designed and furnished for each.
Resort amenities and rules change, and they can differ by section. This guide is about design and furnishing. Confirm rental rules, amenities and fees with the HOA and the resort before you buy or build.
What each resort offers guests
These come from our own resort pages. Confirm current amenities with the resorts.
Windsor Hills: a gated resort with a clubhouse that has a zero-entry pool, water slides, a splash pad, a theater, an arcade and mini golf. Homes include condos, townhomes and single-family pool homes inside the same gate. See our Windsor Hills page.
Windsor Island: a newer resort in Davenport, built around a water park with a lazy river, slides, a zero-entry pool and a splash pad, plus a clubhouse with an arcade, a fitness center and a bar and grille, and outdoor mini golf, sand volleyball, basketball and fire pits. Homes are larger, with private pools. See our Windsor Island page.
What that means for the house
The two resorts put different pressures on the inside of a home. Windsor Hills is an older community with several home types, so many houses are on their first or second round of furniture, and condos, townhomes and houses are all competing for the same search. Windsor Island is newer, with larger homes, so many houses look alike when built, and the guests who book them are often groups.
In both cases, the clubhouse is already a draw. Nobody books a house for the same amenities every other house in the gate has. They book because the photos look current and the beds and rooms suit the group.

A shop-built themed bunk room of the kind that sets a larger home apart.
Windsor Hills: three home types, three plans
Condos: no private pool, so the inside carries the listing. Plan around building access and a compact open room, and put the budget into the primary bedroom and a focal wall in the living area. Our condo furniture package guide goes through the details.
Townhomes: the most common listing type and the most crowded search. Layouts look alike, so a standout bunk or kids' room and a pool deck that matches the photos help. See our townhome design guide.
Houses: more bedrooms and more space to differentiate. A bunk room and a game room are the usual ways to set a house apart from the model next door.
Because the resort is established, an older home may need a refresh more than a first furnishing. We start by marking each room keep, rework or replace. See our refresh and redesign page.
Windsor Island: larger homes and bigger groups
Larger homes at Windsor Island sleep bigger groups, often several families at once. That puts the weight on the shared spaces and on the bedrooms that don't get attention.
Dining and living: plan the seating for the whole group. See our dining planning guide.
Themed bedrooms and bunks: common in newer homes, so quality matters. A well-built themed room beats a bedspread theme.
Primary suites: adult guests judge the house by them. See our primary suite guide.
One entertainment room, done properly: a game room or a theater, not both half-finished. See amenity planning.
Many of these homes come with plain secondary bedrooms from the builder. That is where a modest, well-planned upgrade often makes the most visible difference.
Resales and furnished purchases
At a newer resort, owners often buy a home that was furnished by someone else. That furniture may have been chosen quickly to open for bookings, with matching sets in every bedroom and a theme that's only a bedspread deep. Before you replace anything, review the listing photos against nearby homes and decide what to keep, what to rework and what to replace. Our turnkey versus DIY guide helps you think through who should do the work.
Theme intensity
Windsor Island has a tropical, island feel from its clubhouse to its street names. A little of that carries well in a home, in texture, plants and a calm palette. Too much in every room looks like a costume. At Windsor Hills, the home type usually shapes the design more than the resort does. In both cases, one or two strong rooms and calm secondary rooms usually photograph better than a theme in every bedroom. See our themed room mistakes guide.
Where to put the budget
Windsor Hills condo: the primary bedroom, the living room focal wall and a sleeping nook.
Windsor Hills townhome: a standout kids' or bunk room, the pool deck and any loft.
Windsor Hills house: a signature bunk or game room, and beds throughout.
Windsor Island home: dining and living for the group, the primary suite and one or two well-built themed rooms.
For how spending decisions go wrong, see where owners overspend.
What the two have in common
Guard-gated communities with clubhouse amenities guests already get.
Search results full of similar homes, so the interior is where you stand out.
A need for durable furniture. See durable furniture for vacation rentals.
Resort and HOA rules that can limit what you change, especially outdoors.
Use our furnishing checklist to make sure no room is missed. For another comparison, see our Windsor Hills vs ChampionsGate page, or our Windsor Hills vs Storey Lake guide.
Frequently asked questions
Which resort needs a themed room more?
Both benefit from a signature room. In a larger Windsor Island home, plain secondary bedrooms are a common place to start. In Windsor Hills, a standout kids' or bunk room helps a townhome or house stand out.
Is it worth refreshing an older Windsor Hills home?
Often, when the photos look dated next to nearby listings. We start with the rooms that appear first in the listing.
Do the two resorts have the same rental rules?
Not necessarily. Confirm rules with the HOA before you plan.
Do you furnish homes in both?
Yes. See our Windsor Hills and Windsor Island pages.
Do you compare prices between the resorts?
No. This guide is about design. Ask your agent and the HOA about prices and fees.
How do I start?
Send us your resort, the floor plan and your listing link. We'll show you which rooms to build up first.
Get a quote for your home
Tell us about your home, the resort it's in and the rooms you have in mind, and we'll put together a plan and a quote. Get my quote or call us at 689-777-9954.
Supreme Interior Design, 3401 Commerce Blvd Suite I, Kissimmee, FL 34741.

